A homeowner in Dunnville, Ontario looks out their window one morning to be met with a chilling site. A tall, sinister figure covered head to toe in ice is standing in their front yard. Despite the icicles, its resemblance is clear to the shocked homeowner. It is none other than the spectre of death itself, the Grim Reaper. The Proof Is Out There investigates alleged videos, photos and audio recordings of giant beasts, UFOs, alleged mutants from the deep, and other mysterious phenomenon.